How the attorney runs a law firm conflict check

A law firm conflict check searches current clients, former clients and past matters for conflicts with a new inquiry. The attorney decides whether one exists.

What a conflict check process has to find

A law firm conflict check is only as good as the indexes it reaches. A name that lives only in closed matters or an old system's export is easy to miss, so the steps below call for searching every index and flagging any the search cannot reach before anyone reads the narrative.

  • Names A conflict check fails when the new matter's names never meet the old matter's names.

  • Rule 1.7 ABA Model Rule 1.7 describes when a concurrent conflict exists and when the representation may proceed.

  • Rule 1.9 For former clients, the question is whether the matter is substantially related and the interests materially adverse.

  • Rule 1.10 ABA Model Rule 1.10 imputes most of those conflicts to other lawyers in the firm while they are associated.

Law firm workflows

Steps in the conflict check process

Run these steps on one practice area with closed sample matters before any live file is connected.

  • Freeze the name list Capture the legal name, the name used in the inquiry, adverse parties, and any related entities mentioned.

  • Expand known variants Spelling and punctuation variants are mechanical. A parent or d/b/a is added only if the index or the inquiry states it.

  • Search every index Search open matters, closed matters, and declined inquiries, each behind its existing walls.

  • Label each hit Each hit carries the status the firm already stores: current client, former client, or former-firm association.

  • Attach the attorney's questions Is the matter related? Are interests materially adverse? Is written consent even available?

  • Record the clearance The note names who cleared, when, and whether the firm declined, proceeded, or proceeded with written consent.

Name matching is delegable. Clearance is not.

The search builds the packet. The conflict decision and any consent stay with the attorney.

  • AI prepares the name list and spelling variants from the inquiry.

  • Attorney decides which related entities to add or remove.

  • AI prepares hits with matter, date, party role, and lawyer of record, without the file.

  • Attorney decides whether a hit is the same or a substantially related matter.

  • AI prepares a status tag on each hit from the firm's own fields.

  • Attorney decides whether Rule 1.7, Rule 1.9, or a Rule 1.10 screen applies.

  • AI prepares a clearance line with every outcome left blank.

  • Attorney decides the outcome, with any written consent stored beside it.

Illustrative name collision, not a clearance

  • Invented names, and not a recommendation It shows why a former-client hit needs a person.

  • Input Example Retail LLC asks Example Counsel LLP about a supply dispute with Example Supplier Inc.

  • Output One former-client hit: Example Supplier Inc., 2022, with the lawyer of record and nothing else from the file.

  • Note An attorney who knows the 2022 work judges whether the matters are related. The search cannot.

Law firm conflict check packet, before clearance

Use it on the packet itself. It is a worksheet, not a waiver form or a bar opinion.

  • The legal name and the inquiry name are both listed.

  • Adverse parties and related entities cite the sentence they came from.

  • Added affiliates name the person who added them.

  • All three indexes were searched, or the packet names the missing one.

  • Hits carry no unrelated correspondence.

  • Relatedness and adversity stay blank until an attorney answers.

  • Written consent is stored with the clearance, and a decline is recorded as a decision.

What the conflict search will not open

  • Matter information stays behind its walls, and client consent is recorded before AI processes it.

  • The search will not declare that no conflict exists, impute or remove a conflict under Rule 1.10, or email a waiver.

Where conflict check software fits in practice management

Connect practice management, the document store, and email. New inquiries reach the packet through AI client intake, and a firm that wants the packet built around its own indexes can book a discovery call.

The usual gap is not a missing conflicts module. If the practice management system already has a conflicts search, the firm keeps using it. The trouble is that closed matters, declined inquiries and an old system's export often sit outside that search. Discovery lists every index the firm keeps, and the packet flags any index the search couldn't reach.

The ABA Model Rules are a model, not your state's ethics rules. This page is not legal advice and not a conflict clearance. Precision is not affiliated with the American Bar Association.

Questions

Is a law firm conflict check finished when the names do not match?

No. An empty search is one input. Names can be spelled differently, and entities can be related in ways the index does not store. The attorney still decides.

Can conflict check software replace the attorney's clearance?

No. It can prepare the packet: names, variants, and hits with their stored status. The conflict decision, any consent, and whether to proceed stay with the attorney.

What makes a former client a conflict?

Under Model Rule 1.9, the same or a substantially related matter with materially adverse interests, unless the former client gives informed consent, confirmed in writing. Whether matters are substantially related is the attorney's judgment, not a name match.

Should the prospective client see the hit list?

Not by default. A hit can itself be information relating to another client, so the packet stays with the attorney, who decides what to say about a decline.

What should conflict check software search?

Every index the firm keeps: open matters, closed matters and declined inquiries, checked against the inquiry's names, adverse parties and related entities. If an index can't be searched, the packet should say which one, and the attorney decides what that means for clearance.

Start with one workflow